Category Archives: Pub Crawl NYC Reviews

A brief review of Merchants’ Gate near Columbus Circle in Manhattan

Located at the southern end of the Turnstyle Underground Market at the Columbus Circle A/C subway station, Merchants’ Gate is a rather small beer/cocktail bar adding variety to the dozens of food/coffee shops already in Turnstyle Underground Market.  The bar offers about 10 draught craft beers and another 10 mix of craft and generic bottled/canned beers.  The bar opens daily at 11am and can run as late as 2am daily, though some evenings it may shut earlier than that because Turnstyle Underground Market doesn’t get a lot of foot traffic late night.  The bar is another example of a cashless business, so be ready to pay with credit/debit.

A review of ParkLife in Gowanus, Brooklyn

Located at 636 Degraw Street in Gowanus, Brooklyn, ParkLife is a great spot for outdoor drinking.  Unfortunately, we visited on one of the coldest Saturdays of the year, so outdoor drinking wasn’t really an option for us.  There is a small indoor area that we inhabited during our visit.  We look forward to returning here on a July day when the hot sun is high in the sky.

A brief review of Merrion Row Public House

Located at 119 West 45th Street inside of the Merrion Row Hotel, the Merrion Row Public House is a small bar/restaurant just beyond the main lobby area on the first floor.  The beer selection offers a mix of imports and American craft beers, while the food menu includes Irish and American cuisine.  The layout and look is vastly different from many of the other Irish pubs in the immediate area.  An overall solid spot that we look forward to returning on our next NYC pub crawl through the neighborhood.

A brief review of MJ Smith’s pub in Midtown Manhattan

Located at 9 East 45th Street in Midtown Manhattan, MJ Smith’s picks up where Eamonn’s left off.  We found MJ Smith’s a visual upgrade of Eamonn’s, the former inhabitant of the space.  The layout is generally the same with a long bar in front and a small dining area in back.  The beer selection was slightly underwhelming, as it could have been similar to what you’d find in a midtown pub circa 2002 (ie, not many craft beer selections).  Still, the staff is friendly and the food menu looked intriguing.  MJ Smith’s is a good spot for after-work drinks or if you “miss” your metro-north train at nearby Grand Central Terminal.