Category Archives: Pub Crawl NYC Reviews

McHale's Bar and Grill in Manhattan's Midtown West

A new midtown Irish pub located just east of 51st Street and 8th Avenue.  No, this is not a redux of the classic old New York bar at 46th & 8th that closed for business a few years ago.  The new spot is bi-level, very welcoming addition to the neighborhood.  The staff explained that the name pays homage to the old McHale’s spot, but otherwise has no connection to it.  The front doors and globe lightbulbs at the entrance came from the Helmsley estate!  Beer selection is a mix of the standard tap beers (you know, InBev products plus Sam Adams and a few non-InBev imports) and some local craft beers, including three lines from the nearby Chelsea Brewing Company.  The food menu was not yet finalized during our visit, but it looked promising and we will sample the fare on our next visit!

The lower level

Pony Bar East, 1444 First Avenue (at 75th Street) on Manhattan's Upper East Side

The second location in the Pony Bar empire, Pony Bar East is a new addition to the Upper East Side NYC beer bar crawl.  The spot has a similar feel to the original location in Hell’s Kitchen.  Pony Bar East is also a corner bar location with 20 quality tap beers that rotate frequently.  Most beers are 140z. pours that cost $5.  Pub Crawl NYC can’t wait to return!

Similar set up as the HK location with tables along the walls and whiskey barrels in the middle.
Instead of chalkboards, the beer list is updated electronically

The Churchill, 45 East 28th Street in Manhattan

This spot pays homage to the 20th Century British leader and statesman, Winston Churchill.  Famous quotes are visible throughout the establishment and a framed painting of Churchill sits above the fireplace opposite the bar.  The space is divided into three areas: a front seating area, fitted with high-top tables, followed by the main bar area in the middle and the back makes up the dining area (with restrooms just beyond the dining area).  A dozen mostly-quality tap beers, along with some scotch and whiskey make the drink menu that Churchill would be proud of.  The food menu is a mix of English pub fare and some American bar food.  To quote from the bar’s website, “With a great staff, stone fireplace, and tuneful piano, The Churchill offers an atmosphere like no other bar/restaurant in New York City.”  Having visited nearly every bar in Manhattan, Pub Crawl NYC concurs with that statement.

The entrance on East 28th Street
The main bar area with the dining area visible in the rear
12 quality taps. Definitely a good stop for a craft-beer bar crawl.

Highlights from Memorial Day weekend, part 3

Maslow 6: Picking up where Vino Vino left off at 211 West Broadway, this small wine bar is attached to the wine store. A mix of small plates and a dozen wines by the glass. A good stop for the Tribeca NYC wine bar crawl.
The Gastro Bar: A glorified lobby bar located in the Tryp Hotel on at 345 W. 35th Street. Part bar, part restaurant. A few interesting beers and good happy hour drink specials, but otherwise, not really worth going out of your way for.

Highlights from Memorial Day weekend, part 1

 

Smithfield: A tri-level spot located at 215 West 28th Street. A dozen TVs, 20 tap beers and some tasty food make this place worth a visit.

The Liberty: A new spot at 29 West 35th Street.  Very spacious.  A seating area in the front half of the place, followed by an oval-shaped bar and some additional tables in the back half of the space.  12 tap beers.
Zirzamen: Located in the old Bar Henry space at 90 West Houston Street. Ziramen's look is almost the same as its previous incarnation. A back room offers some live music.