Located in the Hudson Hotel (in the room that used to be Hudson Bar) at 356 West 58th Street, Hudson Common attempts to make the casual beer hall slightly upscale. The room is spacious with some communal tables, as well as some smaller lounge-y tables. A food window is available for walk-up orders and the kitchen texts you when your order is ready (try the boneless buffalo wings!). For a beer hall, we found the beer selection a bit lacking: no more than eight taps, though there were a few local NY craft beer selections. Hudson Common is worth checking out if you’re in the nabe.
Category Archives: Pub Crawl NYC Reviews
A review of Murray Bar in Manhattan's Midtown South
Located at 58 East 34th Street, Murray Bar is located just below Cash Bar (same owners). While Cash Bar is somewhat of a rare find for NYC bars (at least the theme and setting is), Murray Bar is more of an easier-to-find sports bar. Now, by no means is it like the Mercury Bar/Tonic East feel of other nearby sports bars. Place is long and narrow with different nooks and crannies throughout the space. Comfortable spot and friendly staff, but when we return to this building, we’d probably prefer to return upstairs to Cash Bar.
A review of Third Avenue Ale House on Manhattan's Upper East Side
Located at 1644 Third Avenue (at 92nd Street) in the old Brother Jimmy’s Baitshack location, Third Avenue Ale House is a beer bar for the Upper East Side craft-beer focused NYC bar crawl. Offering nearly 30 tap beers and more by the bottle, Third Avenue Ale House feels like it’s been around for a while (even though it opened in late 2012). The food is solid (try the lamb burger!) and the staff is friendly. Bar area in front, followed by a sizeable seating area up a few steps and past the kitchen/bathrooms. This is a place we look forward to returning to.
A review of Grey Bar in Manhattan's Flatiron District
Located at 43 West 26th Street, Grey Bar is in the same location as the former Gstaad. Essentially a sports bar (although not one of those super, upscale sports bars), Grey Bar offers numerous TVs and a spacious place to hang out with friends. For us, though, there just wasn’t anything remarkable about the spot. Probably not a spot worth going out of your way for.
A review of Red Frog on Manhattan's Upper West Side
Located at 2058 Broadway (between 70th and 71st Streets), Red Frog is the third wine bar location of the owners of Chelsea’s The Drunken Horse and Hell’s Kitchen’s Wine Escape. Small cozy spot offers about a dozen wines by the glass as well as some Eastern Mediterranean tapas (try the Lamachune!). Friendly staff too. In all, a great addition to the Upper West Side NYC wine bar crawl.
A review of Tir Na Nog, West 39th Street in Manhattan's Hell's Kitchen
Located at 315 West 39th Street, Tir Na Nog is a bigger, though younger, sibling of the location on Eighth Avenue near Madison Square Garden. Tir Na Nog 39th Street has to be one of the biggest bars (size-wise) in Hell’s Kitchen. The place has two spacious bars and numerous seating/dining areas. We couldn’t count all the TVs in the place. Tir Na Nog 39th Street definitely represents the amelioration of the immediate vicinity of the area south of the Port Authority along 8th Avenue. The bar is worth a visit if you’re nearby.
A review of Draught 55 in Manhattan's Midtown East
Located at 245 E. 55th Street in Midtown East (or is it Sutton Place?), Draught 55 picks up in the location formerly known at Blackstone’s (and, before that, Jimmy Walker’s). Layout is practically identical to its previous incarnations: spacious bar area on the right side of the spot, a slightly elevated dining area takes up the rest of the place (this was where the pool tables were for Jimmy Walker’s). A separate bar area in the very back of the space, beyond the bathrooms and kitchen. The draught beer offerings number around two dozen, nearly all quality craft-beer. The bottled beer selection is solid too. The food is somewhat standard bar/pub fare. Midtown East/ Sutton Place needs more craft-beer focused spot like this and maybe one day, the nabe will have its very own craft-beer focused NYC bar crawl.
A review of Manhattan's Rogue & Canon
Located at 128 West Houston Street (in the old XR Bar space), Rogue & Canon is a new gastropub for the West Houston Street corridor that serves as the border between Greenwich Village and Soho. Sometimes when we go NYC bar crawling, we attempt to decide whether or not the visited spot “counts” as a bar (it’s an age old debate that will rage, seemingly, forever). Well, we’re gonna count Rogue & Canon as a bar (and not a restaurant), but it’s just about as borderline as ever. About half the space is taken up by tables with place settings (which makes the place lean toward “restaurant” distinction). But, during our visit, we noticed that even the patrons seated at those tables were mostly drinking and not eating. So, that’s what tipped this spot toward being a bar. Overall, pleasant staff, eight quality tap beers. Creative cocktails with fascinating names (‘Russian Firing Squad’ and ‘Midnight Train to Georgia’). The food was definitely in that gastropub-like classification (we had the fish and chips). Rogue & Canon is worth a visit next time you’re hanging out in Greenwich Village or Soho.
A review of EVR in Midtown Manhattan
Located at 54 West 39th Street, EVR is a Midtown clubby/lounge-y type spot. Past the long bar area, there’s an elevated DJ booth and a lounge area with low-lying seating, along with a small lounge area on the second floor. During our weeknight visit, the crowd appeared mostly as the after-work type; we could feel the scene changes significantly late nights and weekends. Overall, it’s an okay spot for after-work, but if Irish pubs are a dime-a-dozen in this part of Manhattan, then these upscale clubby/lounge-y type spots are becoming a quarter-a-dozen.


A review of The Cash Bar in Manhattan's Midtown South
Located on the second floor of 58 East 34th Street, The Cash Bar is another speakeasy/cocktail type place. Fairly small and intimate, The Cash Bar feels like a good date place. As the name implies, the space has a ubiquitous cash theme, from the wall paper to the little pile of fake $100 bills in the middle of the room. It’s something a little different for the immediate surrounding neighborhood. Worth a visit next time you are nearby.









